Big Trouble in Big Trenches

Blog Issue #59 - Article 3

October produced two enforcement actions in the same category, two thousand miles apart. In both, the ground gave way on workers who had nothing holding it back.

J.D. Wagoner Excavating: $254,884

On October 7, OSHA proposed $254,884 in penalties against J.D. Wagoner Excavating following a fatal trench collapse.

The citations break down as one willful violation for cave-in protection, two repeat violations covering competent-person inspections and the removal of workers from hazardous conditions, and three serious violations covering hazard-prevention training, safe exit, material setbacks, and roll-in hazards.

Read that list again and notice what it describes. Not one missing item, but the entire protective system around a trench: no cave-in protection going in, nobody competent inspecting it, nobody pulling workers out when conditions changed, no training, no safe way out, and spoil piled where it could roll back in.

The repeat classifications matter most. A repeat violation means OSHA cited this employer for substantially the same hazard before, and it happened again.

A California Tunnel Collapse: $212,500 in Combined Penalties

On October 15, Cal/OSHA announced $212,500 in penalties against two employers following a tunnel collapse near Knights Ferry that killed one worker and seriously injured another. The citations were issued September 30. Investigators found that both companies failed to provide adequate ground support for employees working in the tunnel.

Drill Tech Drilling & Shoring, Inc. of Antioch was cited $95,000, for one serious accident-related ground control violation and one willful-serious accident-related tunnel support violation.

Provost & Pritchard Engineering Group, Inc. of Clovis was cited $117,500, for one serious training violation, one serious accident-related ground control violation, and one willful-serious accident-related tunnel support violation.

Cal/OSHA Chief Debra Lee said deaths and serious injuries from tunnel collapses are “entirely preventable.” Provost & Pritchard has appealed the citations, and a separate Cal/OSHA investigation remains open.

The Same Failure in Two Forms

A trench and a tunnel are different jobs with different standards, different engineering and different crews. The failure underneath both citations is identical: people went into an excavation that had nothing engineered to stop it from closing.

Soil does not give warning in any form a person can act on in time. That is the entire reason cave-in protection is required by the hour rather than by judgment, and why both cases carry a willful classification. Somebody decided the hole was fine.

If your crews enter excavations, the two questions worth asking are who your competent person is and whether that person has authority to stop work. The second one is the one that fails.

Related Posts

Chemical Incidents Aren’t Getting More Common. They’re Getting Deadlier.

Chemical Incidents Aren’t Getting More Common. They’re Getting Deadlier.

11.16.2026 Current Events
Late on Tuesday, October 20, Toledo Fire & Rescue ordered everyone within a mile of 1266 Progress Avenue to leave.…
Read More
Last Call to Update Your HazCom Program

Last Call to Update Your HazCom Program

11.16.2026 Compliance
OSHA revised the Hazard Communication Standard, 29 CFR 1910.1200, on May 20, 2024, bringing it in line with Revision 7…
Read More
Big Trouble in Big Trenches

Big Trouble in Big Trenches

11.16.2026 Current Events
October produced two enforcement actions in the same category, two thousand miles apart. In both, the ground gave way on…
Read More
cta1-img

Explore Our Live and Online Safety Courses

Learn at your own pace online or join an instructor-led live training session.