On-the-Job Training is Adequate Communication of Rules

architect-3979490_1280

A lack of fully documented safety training does not prove inadequate communication of safety rules, according to a July 28 Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission decision.

On Dec. 8, 2015, Angel Brothers Enterprises began work on the installation of a concrete drainage pipe next to a road in LaPorte, TX.

The company’s safety manager determined a trench box would be needed because a nearby intersection would interfere with benching.

But the foreman in charge didn’t use it because he didn’t want to block the entrance to a nearby neighborhood while maneuvering the box into place with an excavator. When OSHA inspected the site, the foreman admitted he let an employee work in the excavation for a short time.

OSHA issued a willful violation, but Angel contested it, arguing the incident was a result of the foreman’s unforeseeable employee misconduct.

Toolbox Talks Count

An administrative law judge found Angel didn’t effectively enforce its safety rules so upheld the citation.

She also found Angel couldn’t prove adequate communication of the rule because its training was on-the-job, verbal and not fully documented.

On review, the commission agreed Angel failed to prove unforeseeable employee misconduct but found there was more than enough evidence the company communicated its safety rules using toolbox talks and other on-the-job methods.

Purchase NASP’s Certified Safety Manager Course

Related Posts

Chemical Incidents Aren’t Getting More Common. They’re Getting Deadlier.

Chemical Incidents Aren’t Getting More Common. They’re Getting Deadlier.

11.16.2026 Current Events
Late on Tuesday, October 20, Toledo Fire & Rescue ordered everyone within a mile of 1266 Progress Avenue to leave.…
Read More
Last Call to Update Your HazCom Program

Last Call to Update Your HazCom Program

11.16.2026 Compliance
OSHA revised the Hazard Communication Standard, 29 CFR 1910.1200, on May 20, 2024, bringing it in line with Revision 7…
Read More
Big Trouble in Big Trenches

Big Trouble in Big Trenches

11.16.2026 Current Events
October produced two enforcement actions in the same category, two thousand miles apart. In both, the ground gave way on…
Read More
cta1-img

Explore Our Live and Online Safety Courses

Learn at your own pace online or join an instructor-led live training session.